Proudly Serving New Jersey + Beyond

Available 24/7 | Consultation is Free

Firm Logo

Navigating Domestic Violence Charges in New Jersey: Understanding Your Legal Defenses

Introduction to Domestic Violence Laws in New Jersey

In the intricate realm of New Jersey law, domestic violence is a particularly sensitive and emotionally charged area. Protecting victims is paramount, yet it’s equally important for those accused to understand their rights, especially when they believe the charges are unfounded. The stakes in New Jersey are particularly high, necessitating a deep understanding of potential defenses. The law firm of Attorneys Hartman, Chartered, offers valuable insights into these defenses, ensuring a balanced and informed approach to such serious allegations.

The Serious Implications of Domestic Violence Charges

Domestic violence charges are not to be taken lightly. Such allegations can lead to severe repercussions, both legally and personally. New Jersey law considers acts like assault, harassment, and threats within the domestic sphere as punishable offenses. Convictions can lead to imprisonment, restraining orders, fines, and long-lasting impacts on one’s record.

Beyond the legal ramifications, those charged may face social ostracization, loss of child custody, and employment challenges. This underscores the critical need for understanding and potentially utilizing available defenses.

Domestic violence charges are grave matters with potential long-term legal and personal consequences. It’s imperative for those accused to be familiar with the common defenses used in these cases. However, it’s crucial to remember that each case is unique, and the applicability of these defenses will vary based on individual circumstances.

False Accusations

  • Description: It’s not uncommon for one party to falsely accuse the other of domestic violence. Motives can range from jealousy, anger, desire for revenge, or gaining an advantage in custody battles.
  • Application: To successfully use this defense, the accused often needs to prove a motive for the false accusation and provide evidence that the accusations are indeed false.

Lack of Evidence

  • Description: The burden of proof lies with the prosecution. They must provide enough evidence to prove the accused’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
  • Application: If there isn’t sufficient evidence to substantiate the charges, the defendant can motion for a dismissal based on this ground.


  • Description: The accused might claim they were acting in self-defense, indicating that the alleged victim was actually the aggressor.
  • Application: To effectively use this defense, the accused must provide evidence showing they had a genuine belief they were in imminent danger and that their response was proportionate.


  • Description: The accused claims they were elsewhere when the alleged incident occurred and, therefore, couldn’t have committed the act.
  • Application: Solid evidence, like video footage or credible witnesses, can validate an alibi defense.

Mistaken Identity

  • Description: Sometimes, especially in cases where the alleged attacker wasn’t clearly seen, the wrong person may be accused.
  • Application: Proving mistaken identity might involve demonstrating inconsistencies in the victim’s description and the accused’s actual appearance or providing evidence that points towards another individual.


  • Description: In rare circumstances, the defense might argue that the alleged victim consented to a certain act, making it non-abusive.
  • Application: This defense is tricky and isn’t common. Proving it usually requires direct evidence like communications or witness statements.

Constitutional Violations

  • Description: If the defendant’s rights were violated during the investigation or arrest, such as an illegal search, the evidence obtained might be dismissed.
  • Application: A seasoned lawyer can file a motion to suppress evidence obtained through unconstitutional means.

Credibility of Witnesses

  • Description: The defense might challenge the credibility of witnesses, including the alleged victim.
  • Application: Evidence of bias, inconsistencies in statements, or prior false accusations can be used to question a witness’s reliability.

Selecting the right defense should be based on the facts of the case and the advice of a seasoned criminal defense attorney. Not all defenses will be applicable or effective in every situation. When faced with domestic violence charges, it’s crucial to consult with a legal professional to navigate the complexities of the case effectively.

Navigating domestic violence charges without experienced legal representation is like navigating treacherous waters without a compass. Here’s why hiring a professional is crucial:

  • Understanding of the Law: Lawyers at firms like Attorneys Hartman, Chartered, have in-depth knowledge of New Jersey’s domestic violence laws, ensuring clients make informed decisions.
  • Evidence Collection and Analysis: They can help gather evidence, work with experts, and analyze data that might be critical for the defense.
  • Protection of Rights: Accused individuals might not be aware of all their rights. A competent attorney ensures those rights are protected throughout the legal process.
  • Negotiation Skills: In some situations, it might be beneficial to negotiate with the prosecution for a reduced sentence or alternative solutions. This is where seasoned domestic violence attorneys can make a significant difference.

Understanding the legal process in New Jersey can alleviate stress and prepare you for what lies ahead. Here’s a brief overview of the legal process related to domestic violence charges in New Jersey:

Arrest and Charges

  • What Happens: If there’s probable cause to believe domestic violence occurred, the alleged perpetrator might be arrested. Once arrested, formal charges will be filed.
  • What to Expect: The accused might be taken into custody, photographed, fingerprinted, and held until a bail hearing or released on a summons.

First Appearance in Court

  • What Happens: The defendant is brought before a judge for the first time.
  • What to Expect: The charges will be read, the defendant’s rights will be explained, and bail conditions will be set. It’s essential to have legal representation at this stage, even if you haven’t hired a private attorney yet.

Discovery Phase

  • What Happens: This is the pre-trial phase where both the prosecution and defense gather and share evidence.
  • What to Expect: Expect exchanges of police reports, photographs, witness statements, and other relevant evidence. Your attorney will assess the evidence’s strength, seek any missing information, and start formulating a defense strategy.

Pre-Trial Motions

  • What Happens: Before the actual trial, attorneys from both sides can file motions to request the court take specific actions.
  • What to Expect: Motions can range from requests to dismiss charges due to insufficient evidence or violations of constitutional rights, to suppressing certain evidence from being presented during the trial. This step can significantly shape the trajectory of the case.

Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI)

  • What Happens: For first-time offenders, New Jersey offers a Pre-Trial Intervention program. If accepted and completed successfully, charges can be dismissed.
  • What to Expect: If eligible, you’ll undergo a screening process. If accepted into PTI, expect counseling, restitution, or community service. It’s crucial to comply fully with the program’s requirements.


  • What Happens: If no plea deal or intervention is reached, the case goes to trial.
  • What to Expect: Both sides present evidence, call and cross-examine witnesses, and make closing arguments. Either a judge or a jury will determine the verdict. Throughout this process, your attorney will challenge the prosecution’s evidence, present defenses, and work to establish reasonable doubt.


  • What Happens: If the verdict is guilty, the court will decide the appropriate punishment.
  • What to Expect: Depending on the severity of the domestic violence charge and any prior criminal history, consequences can range from probation, counseling, and community service to fines, restraining orders, and imprisonment.

Domestic violence charges in New Jersey carry significant weight. Whether you believe you’ve been falsely accused or think there are grounds for a valid defense, understanding your options is paramount. Remember, every case is unique. While this post outlines general defenses, it’s vital to consult with experienced professionals for tailored advice.

If you or someone you know is facing such charges and needs guidance, reach out to Attorneys Hartman, Chartered. Our team of dedicated attorneys is here to help, ensuring you have the best representation and defense strategy tailored to your specific circumstances.

Contact us for a consultation today.

Firm Logo
Moorestown Office68 E. Main StreetMoorestown, NJ 08057
Fax: 856.273.8617
Map + Directions
Moorestown Office68 E. Main StreetMoorestown, NJ 08057
Fax: 856.273.8617
Map + Directions